Market: 631.537.0633

Receive Daily Specials

On January 1st, 2000, after almost 30 years of dedicating his life to the progress of the store, John Haessler decided to put the same energy towards his family and hobbies. Colin Mather, after spending 13 years under John’s tutelage, became the new owner. Colin has made a few physical changes, but the core motto of The Seafood Shop remains the same, “The Freshest and Finest”. That motto extends to everything we do and our customers are always treated like family.

The life of The Seafood Shop reads like a story, with lots of colorful characters.
So come on in and get your name on the page. We’ll be looking for you.

Daily Specials

 Receive Daily Specials
Daily emailed Specials of the Day
often with discounts and treats.


Take Out Menu

 Our Take Out Menu
Select from our delicious Take Out Menu from homemade soups to fresh entrees.


Event Catering

Catering Menus
and other information
for your Catering Event!


  • Darla Smith Avatar
    Darla Smith

    Food was delicious

  • Alice Musial Avatar
    Alice Musial

    The Seafood is absolutely delicious.Tiny place packed with incredible mouth watering flavors. Great variety of fresh and frozen Seafood sourced from a variety of different places.Impressive menue ,extremely knowledgeable Staff. It's truely a Treasure!!!

  • Miranda Terceira Avatar
    Miranda Terceira

    Super friendly people and some of the best seafood I've had. We will be returning customers for sure!

  • Smooth Black202 Avatar
    Smooth Black202

    A little pricey but seems like fresh food

  • Stephen G. Avatar
    Stephen G.
    5 star rating

    We have been shopping there for more than 20 years, but this was the first time I asked them to cater a birthday party for me on a boat no less. They were absolutely amazing in every way. The office was so great in helping me plan a menu (because I'm helpless). The price was fair and the staff they sent couldn't t have been more attentive and personable. Now for the food - simply delicious. We had no capability to serve hot food so the menu featured room temperature appetizers with special kudos for the mini lobster rolls and crab cakes. The raw bar onboard was also superb with the freshest and sweetest shrink, clams and oysters. Main course was salmon that was moist and so delicious. The staff even helped with the birthday cake that came from elsewhere. All in all it was a night to remember thanks in a large part to the Seafood Shop!!


More Testimonials

Scroll to Top